Arizona AG sues Scottsdale college district, previous board president more than public comment ban through meetings

NEWYou can now hear to WHD News articles!

Arizona Attorney Basic Mark Brnovich is suing the Scottsdale Unified School District (SUSD) and its then-governing board president more than allegations that they prohibited the community from commenting on mask mandates and other difficulties of worry all through digital meetings held last summer months. 

Brnovich, a Republican, mentioned Jann-Michael Greenburg restricted the public’s capability to voice their thoughts on whether to carry out a mask need all through two conferences on Aug. 17 and Aug. 23, 2021, according to court docket paperwork.

In the course of the first conference, the board was slated to go over the school district’s educational time product for the 2021-22 school 12 months and the prospective mask prerequisite. The meeting agenda mentioned the event would be broken up into two areas – a “public listening to” for the time design situation and a “particular assembly” for issue relevant to masks. At the finish of the public assembly part, the community would be permitted to comment but the agenda did not say the subject issue of the reviews would be minimal to the instructional time model, the lawsuit explained. 

“The Board regularly reduce off any speaker whenever Greenburg decided that the subject matter reviewed strayed as well significantly from the 2021-2022 tutorial time product,” the lawsuit states. “In so undertaking, the Board, by way of Greenburg, used a written content-primarily based restriction on speech.”


Former Scottsdale school board President Jann-Michael Greenburg (Scottsdale Unified School District) Parents protest at a Scottsdale school board meeting. Arizona Attorney General Mark Brnovich is suing Greenburg and the school district for allegedly not allowing the public to comment on certain matters in a series of board meetings last year.

Previous Scottsdale faculty board President Jann-Michael Greenburg (Scottsdale Unified School District) Mother and father protest at a Scottsdale faculty board conference. Arizona Attorney Typical Mark Brnovich is suing Greenburg and the college district for allegedly not making it possible for the general public to remark on particular matters in a collection of board meetings final calendar year.
((Scottsdale Unified University District/Amy Carney)

“The Board purposely bifurcated the agenda for the August 17, 2021, conference to avoid making it possible for general public remark on a proposed mask mandate and other items stated on the agenda underneath the “specific meeting,” it reported. 

A 2nd virtual assembly on Aug. 23, 2021, went the way of the to start with, with Greenburg only permitting members of the public to comment on the educational time product make any difference. Only two people created reviews, the lawsuit mentioned. 

Next that meeting, Brnovich’s office been given issues about the method in which both equally gatherings have been held, the lawsuit explained. The school board advised the legal professional general’s office environment it was permitted to implement “information limitations.”

“For the reason that the Open up Meeting Legislation does not allow a community overall body to accept community remark via any system other than an ‘open contact to the general public,’ the Board, largely by way of Mr. Greenburg, violated the Open up Meeting Law by proscribing the topic subject on which the general public could remark to the educational time model,” the complaint states.

The board held a regular conference on Aug. 24, but people wishing to present general public comment were being needed to do so in person regardless of the assembly staying reside-streamed and no viewers was permitted in man or woman, the lawsuit states. All those who showed up to the meeting have been escorted into the conference area separately. 


Kari Lake video screenshot of moms of Scottsdale Unified School District.

Kari Lake online video screenshot of mothers of Scottsdale Unified Faculty District.
(Kari Lake for Congress)

1 guardian explained inappropriate resources had been remaining furnished to college students. 

“Greenburg interrupted the parent’s responses to assert that the comments were being not true and to endeavor to explain why,” court docket files reported. “The mum or dad effectively defined to Greenburg that he is not permitted to interrupt general public remarks. 

Greenburg responded and ended his remarks with: “Jesus F****** Christ individuals!” underneath his breath, according to a video clip of the conference. WHD News has reached out to the faculty district and Greenburg. 

Greenburg and the district are also currently being sued by 3 dad and mom more than a “dossier” allegedly aimed at scary them into silence after they criticized him. That lawsuit alleged Greenburg, his father and his father’s wife, conspired to punish dissenting voices.

The alleged file includes 47 parents who spoke out at school board conferences. It includes Social Safety numbers, history checks, a divorce paper, mortgage paperwork, trade certifications, and screenshots of Facebook posts. 

Parents protest at a Scottsdale school board meeting. Photo courtesy Amy Carney

Dad and mom protest at a Scottsdale faculty board conference. Photo courtesy Amy Carney
(Amy Carney)

Simply click Listed here TO GET THE WHD News App

The lawsuit promises that the defendants “misused District resources and what really should have been private, shielded guardian communications to the District to retaliate towards Plaintiffs for their secured speech.”

WHD News’ Tyler O’Neil contributed to this report. 

You may also like